Literature and Fantasy

Although I try really hard to use only reality based books, I have to honestly say that I am not 100%.Once in a while a book with animals talking sneaks its way in! For picture books I look for beautiful illustrations and interesting stories. I do read The Kissing Hand the first day of school basically because I have never found a book that is better than that on the subject of transition.

Books of the popular culture like Thomas the Train and Dora are not in my class and if children bring them in, they show their favorite page on the circle and out the book in their cubby. I am careful that what I read aloud to children has educational value...... When a child asks why.... I explain honestly that it will not help our learning.

I have never thought so much about exaggerations but I think a lot about offering a multicultural view of the world and people in it through the literature!


Posted by: "Cathie Perolman"


We had a HUGE discussion about this on this list last year or so and it gave me the motivation to "clean out" my class library. I took out all books that had animals portrayed as people, talking animals and in animate objects, etc. The children have never missed them. There are other books that seemed too fantasy based where it was quite confusing to the children. My feeling is that I am the teacher who the children look up to, and although parents are probably reading fantasy books, sharing fantasy stories, etc, the children know that they can count on me to help them sort out what is real and what is not real. I do have a section of fiction books, although small and non commercial, they passed my inspection years ago and remain on the shelf. To tell you the truth, the children rarely choose one of those books for me to read to them. They usually choose reality books about transportation(current), the seasons, planets, animals, plants and other people and places around the world.


2. If you have a "reality" only policy for books, do you believe that children are not influenced by outside literature or television programming. (Thomas the Tank, Dora Explorer)
Sure they are influenced but just like they know there are different rules at home then at school(it's ok to climb up slides at home, but not at school), they know without reminders what conversations will be at school. That doesn't mean that a cartoon character does not come up among friends, but the influence is not that major in the classroom. Of course, we have in our parent handbook, talk about such things (our classroom is reality based and what that means) so we tend to attract families that share that way of thinking. It is a family value. We still have occasional child that seems obsessed with a cartoon character from home, but I have noticed less children coming from homes that use tv as babysitters like I did at my last school.


Maureen


I don't think that the schools that I worked for had a "policy" about literature. I think that they left it to our descretion. My job before I was trained and was working as an assistant was to bring library books that I selected to school. This was a lesson for the children that the library is an interesting place full of wonderful books to borrow. I had a couple real lapses where I didn't read the books and brought them in and my teacher gave me a look. One was about a man dying of aids. This is a great tool for a parent to child situation but hardly appropriate for a class of thirty preschoolers. My other one was about a boy who fantasized turning himself into a monster and eating his enemies. She started to read this one before we both realized what the plot entailed. Needless to say I "always" read the books that I brought in from then on.


Posted by: "marie.hopkinson@comcast.net"